So over the last two months or so I've read 37 books by Sean Phillips and Ed Brubaker, totalling over 4500 pages and representing most, but not quite all, of their comic book collaborations from 2003 to 2025 (and still on-going with two books scheduled in 2026 and likely beyond, unless the boys go Hollywood with their TV deal and leave comics behind). I've read them intermittently over the years, maybe about half of their signature collaboration CRIMINAL (TV adaptation allegedly upcoming for several years now), the first book or two of most of the other serializations (FATALE, THE FADE OUT, KILL OR BE KILLED) and a few of their one-shot books. Completely new to me are their first major series (following a series Phillips just inked and some Batman stuff), the DC/Wildstorm SLEEPER, INCOGNITO and a few other one-shot books and most of the hardcover original RECKLESS series.
Before I go on, I do want to plug the entity that made this reading possible in a quick and affordable manner, the Toronto Public Library. If anyone ever asks what's the best comic book store in Toronto, the hidden answer is the library system. Over 27,000 different items (with between one and several dozen copies of each) available for you to take home at the low, low price of nothing if you live or work in the city (and a not unreasonable $150 a year if you don't. $3 a week, that's not even a coffee or a subway fare), plus many thousands more for in-library use in some remarkable special collections, including some very rare and/or expensive things, plus free access to a few thousand more digitally through the Overdrive/Libby and Hoopla services. That's in addition to pretty much a lifetime supply of non-comic books (can such a thing exist?), music and movies both in print and digital. All of this well catalogued, primarily by creator as the good lord intended (well, age level and then creator, the good lord does have to allow for community standards), but also searchable by other key words, conveniently delivered (except the special collections) to any of a hundred locations probably a short walk or bus ride from you. And with a professional staff which will mostly leave you alone if you look like you know what you're doing, but also provide trained help in finding items you're interested in without feeling the need to explain who they'd think would win in a fight between Thor and Conan (Thor, if you were wondering). They also have one of the most liberal return policies of any comic store I know. They'll not only take everything back for a full refund, but will eventually charge you extra if you don't use their return policy. Now I ask you, is that any way to run a railroad?
(most of the books pictured above, a few I already returned)
But seriously, the public library is a valuable and far under-utilized service, and Toronto is lucky to have such an excellent system, not just for comics (but, obviously, most importantly for comics...) but all sorts of services. Hopefully you live in an area with a similarly valuable public utility, and if not badger your local government until you do.
TPL was able to get me 37 of the 38 books I was looking for in this project, everything except INCOGNITO - BAD INFLUENCES, the second and final book of that series, and given the fact that for whatever reason Brubaker and Phillips haven't chosen to re-publish that series under their current deal at Image, so the last edition is now some 15 years old, that's understandable. And I can find a copy easily enough. They could also provide two anthologies with CRIMINAL short stories, NOIR and LIBERTY, if I didn't already have them.
So, the history, for those who don't know (skip ahead if you do for my thoughts on the book, skip the whole thing if you don't care about those). Sean Phillips was a very prolific comics artist in the British industry in the 1980s, and starting in 1990 did a lot of work for US publishers, most notably DC's horror/fantasy Vertigo line (even before it had that name). Ed Brubaker started as a writer/artist on some small press and independent comics, with work strongly reminiscent of the Hernandez Brothers (PURGATORY USA) and Chester Brown (LOWLIFE). Later on he concentrated on writing with a few well regarded short stories, eventually finding his way to DC/Vertigo, where, oddly, Sean Phillips ended up inking a series Brubaker wrote with artist Michael Lark, SCENE OF THE CRIME (which TPL does have available digitally, and I'll read eventually). Later Brubaker would do a lot of Batman stories, and Phillips would draw a few of them. By 2003 DC had bought the Jim Lee's Wildstorm line (previously published through Image) and both Brubaker and Phillips did some work separately for that line. They were paired together for a series called SLEEPER, which sold okay as a serial but did quite a bit better critically and later in sales of the collections. That lasted for two series of 12 issues, oddly called "seasons". By 2006 Brubaker was well established writing for Marvel's superhero line. At that time Marvel had a line for their creators under exclusive contracts to do creator-owned work, the mostly forgotten Icon imprint. Brubaker and Phillips launched their series CRIMINAL through that line with various series and collections until 2011, in the later years alternating with two mini-series of the super-hero book INCOGNITO.
Then in 2012 they set up shop at Image, serializing and later collecting FATALE (24 issues), THE FADE OUT (12 issues) and KILL OR BE KILLED (20 issues) over the next six+ years, along with some new one-shots and collections of the old Marvel CRIMINAL stories. In 2018 they released a longer CRIMINAL story as an original hardcover, MY HEROES HAVE ALWAYS BEEN JUNKIES, before returning to a serialized CRIMINAL series for a dozen issues up to 2020. But JUNKIES must have done well, after that they've been mostly doing longer hardcover originals, with four stand-alone books and five books of the RECKLESS series coming out between 2020 and 2024. Last year they returned to CRIMINAL (as noted, maybe soon to be a TV series) with a massive 200-page book, KNIVES (11th in the CRIMINAL series), which is the most recent thing I've read. Since then they've also done another single issue CRIMINAL one-shot and have both another CRIMINAL hardcover and another stand-alone book scheduled for later this year.
That's the history (with, yes, a lot of gaps). Now the books. With all of them available at once, I decided to mix it up on the reading order. I could have gone strictly chronological, which appeals to part of my brain, but doesn't have a lot of variety (I mean, four collections of SLEEPER to start, followed by six of CRIMINAL with only one INCOGNITO to break it up, then five of FATALE...). Alphabetical appeals to another part of the brain, but that part is silly and we don't listens to it. I decided to put the four non-CRIMINAL serialized books in sequence so I'd get to them in order, but never consecutive volumes of the same series. Then I randomly stuck the CRIMINAL*, RECKLESS* and stand-alone books on the shelf, again with the only rule being no consecutive books of the same series (treating "stand-alone" as a series), so no matter how much I like a book, I won't read another in the same series without reading at least two or three other books. Why create so many convoluted rules? Because I can (and because I'm free to ignore them for any or no reason, though in this case I didn't).
[* both those series already have have jumping timelines, and that and their pulp fiction rooted origins encourage reading them in any order you happen to encounter them]
So as noted 500 paragraphs north, this took a little over two months. It's not fair to any creator to consume over 4500 pages of their work, the product of over two decades of hard labour, over so little time, but if there's one thing I learned from these books, it's that life is seldom fair. There are a few tics in their styles which stand out reading so much at once, but obviously I wouldn't have kept reading until I got to the end if I wasn't overall enjoying it. After a suitable gap, maybe a year, I even plan on re-reading them at a more leisurely pace. But some very quick thoughts on them at this point...
SLEEPER was all new to me, heard a lot of praise for it in the day, never got around to it. It's set in the very convoluted Wildstorm universe that Jim Lee & Co. created back in 1992 and developed with hired hands of variable talent over the next few years before selling it all to DC, who only made it more convoluted. The story involves an agent, Holden Carver, from a shadowy government organization being sent undercover by his boss Lynch to infiltrate a shadowy international criminal organization run by Tao (who's one of the few characters here I understand, coming from the Alan Moore written run of WILDCATS). In a previous series by Brubaker (POINT BLANK with artist Colin Wilson, which I did read before reading SLEEPER) Lynch is shot and comatose, leaving Carver without any way of proving he was working undercover. Things progress from there. This is overlong at 24 issues, and mired in some nonsense continuity that it tries valiantly to explain, but doesn't always succeed, and I didn't really care for the ending. But overall I liked it, the good parts make up for the flaws, and I'm glad I read it. 7/10
CRIMINAL is the big one, eleven books so far, and I've taken so long to write this that a twelfth has come out, which should be available soon. It's mostly the story of the nominative determinist Lawless family of Bay City and the people unfortunate enough to be in their sphere of influence over the past half century. Each book stands alone, but builds on the past, feeling free not to make all the connections explicit but leave them to the reader to pick up. While staying firmly in pulp tradition, there are also a lot of clever stylistic choices in each book. Definitely looking forward to more and re-reading it, this is probably the series I'm most likely to buy for my own collection in some form. 4½ stars
INCOGNITO is pretty much a basic super-hero (or rather super-villain) story, ratcheted up in the sex and violence department. It's about a villain, Zack Overkill, who is in witness protection until his past catches up with him. This was okay, maybe when I read the second series I'll like it more. Both Phillips and Brubaker have done a lot of super-hero comics in their day, and it's interesting to see them do it without restraints, but it's played pretty straight, no parody elements like a lot of "extreme" super-hero stories. Incomplete, pending part 2
FATALE, THE FADE OUT and KILL OR BE KILLED, I kind of had similar feelings towards, with varying degrees of severity. They start strong, don't have enough story to maintain the number of pages they've been given, really drift in the middle, pick up a bit at the end, but aren't completely satisfyingly tied up. Of the three, THE FADE OUT is the best, as the shortest, most straightforward (a tale of murder and intrigue in old Hollywood) and devoid of fantasy elements. FATALE I'm not sure if I missed something, I might enjoy more if I read it straight through. KILL OR BE KILLED is the one I'm most likely to never read again. Overall for the group, C+
There are four stand-alone books, PULP, WHERE THE BODY WAS, NIGHT FEVER and HOUSES OF THE UNHOLY. Overall the most successful was THE BODY, that I can recommend unconditionally. It has an interesting story structure, some well drawn out characters that you could care about. Next was PULP, which started out as a straightforward story of a pulp fiction writer in the 1930s before getting a bit ridiculous, but its heart was in the right place. NIGHT and HOUSES were okay, nothing wrong, just nothing new. Collectively 82.7%
And finally the RECKLESS series, five original hardcovers published in under two years from 2020 to 2022, and nothing since. They tell stories set over decades in the life of Ethan Reckless, who like the Lawless clan of Bay City lives up to his name while living in Los Angeles working as a private eye after his previous life as an undercover agent. This series switches off with CRIMINAL as my favourite of the Phillips/Brubaker collaborations, and I could very much see adding some or all of them to my collection at some point. Presumably there is going to be at least one more book (Reckless' narration is from far in the future of the published books, and hints at some major events to come). 3.8 GPA







































